Menu of Andy's Pizza in Elba, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Andy’s Pizza, nestled in Elba, NY, offers a compelling mix of classic and specialty pizzas alongside a well-rounded menu of sides and subs that capture the essence of authentic American comfort food. This local gem stands out not just for its food but for the genuine warmth of its service, making it a destination worth returning to.

The highlight undoubtedly is their pizza selection. From the specialty “The Hog” to the crowd-pleasing chicken finger pizza topped with a creamy white sauce, Andy’s consistently delivers pies with balanced flavors and pleasing textures. Customers often praise the crust for its ideal chew and the fresh ingredients that never disappoint. One regular even mentions the option to request a “saucy” pizza, indicating the kitchen’s flexibility in catering to individual tastes, a rare and appreciated touch.

The side orders complement the pizzas beautifully. The Cajun and loaded fries bring a bold, savory punch, while the mozzarella sticks and fried dough add a satisfying, crispy indulgence. Their wings and subs also stand out — flavorful, generous, and made with quality components. The small steak sub, for example, received accolades for its grilled roll and fresh toppings, making it a noteworthy meal on the go.

What truly enriches the Andy’s Pizza experience is the personal attention customers receive. Reviews highlight how staff members remember preferences and go the extra mile to customize dishes. This level of care, paired with consistently solid food quality, sets Andy’s apart from typical chain-style pizzerias.

Though located somewhat off the main path, the loyal clientele speaks volumes. Whether you’re passing through on a road trip or making a deliberate drive from neighboring towns, Andy’s Pizza offers both a delicious meal and a warm, inviting atmosphere. It’s easy to see why many dub this spot the best pizza in the area—flavorful, hearty, and served with a smile.

In summary, Andy’s Pizza delivers on every front: taste, variety, value, and customer service. For lovers of traditional pizza, robust sides, and satisfying subs, it’s a location that deserves a top spot on your list when hunger strikes in Elba, NY.